Menu of Milky Ways Ice Cream & Cereal Bar in Coram, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Milky Ways Ice Cream & Cereal Bar in Coram, NY, is a vibrant haven for anyone craving a playful and indulgent twist on classic ice cream treats. Nestled at 2229 Rte 112, this spot brilliantly marries nostalgia with creative flair by combining creamy ice cream with an impressive array of cereals, toppings, and drizzles. The brand thrives on transforming simple ingredients into cosmic masterpieces, as reflected in their diverse menu and stand-out specials.

The menu at Milky Ways offers an enticing selection that caters to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters alike. Their ice cream cups and shakes are generous in size, with options like the XL Cup Ice Cream and Adult Cup Ice Cream providing solid value. But what truly elevates the experience are the specialty swirls and milkshakes, where iconic cereals such as Fruity Pebbles, Trix, Lucky Charms, and Captain Crunch Berries become more than just cereal—they infuse each scoop with vibrant texture and whimsical flavor.

Highlight desserts such as the Silly Rabbit Special Swirl and Meet The Flinstones Special Swirl showcase a masterful blend of vanilla ice cream with cereal, brownie bites, cookie dough, and honey or chocolate drizzle, creating layers of taste and crunch that resonate deeply with childhood memories. Similarly, the milkshakes like the Chunky Monkey Special—rich with bananas, Nutter Butter, and peanut butter drizzle—and the Cactus Jack Special featuring Reese's puffs and peanut butter cups, illustrate the brand’s commitment to bold and satisfying flavor combinations.

What makes Milky Ways truly exceptional is the seamless integration of texture and taste: the creaminess of vanilla ice cream acts as the perfect canvas for popcorn, brownie bites, sour gummy worms, and various rich sauces like hot fudge and caramel. This layering builds a multisensory experience where every bite captures a new discovery, balancing sweetness, crunch, and smoothness.

Beyond the menu, the attentive and knowledgeable staff stand out as part of the brand’s charm. They offer friendly guidance to navigate the seemingly endless possibilities, easing any choice overload with personalized recommendations. Whether you lean toward fruity blends or chocolatey decadence, there’s a reassuring confidence in the care and creativity they bring. This isn’t just about ordering ice cream—it's about crafting a custom treat that feels made just for you.

Customer feedback highlights this appeal: from the exuberance over cereal selections that feel like a walk down memory lane, to praise for the freshness and creaminess of the ice cream itself, Milky Ways consistently delivers a joyful, clean, and inviting atmosphere. The space-themed decor adds a fun, whimsical touch that aligns perfectly with the brand’s playful concept.

In summary, Milky Ways Ice Cream & Cereal Bar isn’t just another ice cream shop; it’s a destination where creativity meets comfort food. The innovative cereal-infused ice creams and milkshakes offer a unique portal back to childhood with a sophisticated adult twist. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Coram, a visit here promises a sweet escape filled with layered textures, nostalgic flavors, and stellar service—making every scoop a memorable experience.